Policyholder Attorney vs. Insurance Defense Lawyer

Policyholder Attorney vs. Insurance Defense Lawyer

| Blog

Policyholder Attorney vs. Insurance Defense Lawyer: Why Many Large Firms Can’t Represent You

A policyholder attorney represents you, the insured, when your insurance company denies, delays or underpays a claim. An insurance defense lawyer is usually hired and paid by the insurer to defend you against someone else’s claim. Many large firms also do work for insurers, which creates conflicts that stop them from suing those same insurers on your behalf.

When a claim goes wrong, the first question most business owners ask is “Who do I call?” The answer depends on whose side the lawyer is on. In insurance disputes, that question matters more than in almost any other area of law.

What does an insurance defense lawyer do?

An insurance defense lawyer defends a policyholder who has been sued by a third party. Under a liability policy, the insurer has a duty to defend. It meets that duty by hiring a lawyer from its own panel of approved firms.

In Arizona, that lawyer owes professional duties to you, the insured. But the insurer chose them, pays their invoices and sends them repeat business. When your interests and the insurer’s interests split, for example over whether a claim is covered, that relationship can get complicated.

What does a policyholder attorney do?

A policyholder attorney works only for the insured, never for the insurance company. Typical matters include:

  • Denied or underpaid property, liability, builder’s risk and business interruption claims
  • Insurers that refuse to defend or that defend under a “reservation of rights”
  • Disputes over policy wording, exclusions and coverage limits
  • Insurance bad faith claims, when an insurer unreasonably denies or delays what it owes

In short, a defense lawyer defends you against a third party. A policyholder attorney takes on your own insurer.

Why can’t many large law firms represent policyholders?

Many large regional and national firms represent insurance companies, banks and other financial institutions with ties to insurers. Under the ethics rules, a firm generally cannot sue a current client. Even when no formal conflict exists, many firms turn down policyholder cases to protect valuable insurer relationships.

Troy Froderman saw this first-hand during decades at large and international firms. On It’s Law, Episode 1, he explained that large national firms are often conflicted out of representing policyholders. That gap is one reason he and Scott Ryan founded FR Law Group in 2017. FRL has no insurer clients, so it is free to pursue any carrier on a policyholder’s behalf.

How do I know if a lawyer has a conflict with my insurer?

Ask directly before you share details of your claim:

  1. Does your firm represent any insurance companies, including my carrier?
  2. Has your firm defended insureds on panel assignments from my carrier?
  3. Do you represent banks, brokers or other companies affiliated with my insurer?
  4. Would anything stop you from suing my insurer, or from taking the case to trial?

A firm that represents policyholders only should be able to answer “no” to all four without hesitation.

What is a reservation of rights letter, and why does it matter?

A reservation of rights letter means your insurer agrees to defend you for now but keeps the right to deny coverage later. It often arrives early in a lawsuit, and many business owners file it away without realizing what it signals.

It matters because your interests and your insurer’s interests have now split. The insurer is paying for your defense while also building reasons not to pay a judgment or settlement. Facts uncovered in the defense, such as whether damage was intentional or when it happened, can decide coverage. That is exactly when you need a lawyer who answers only to you.

A policyholder attorney can review the letter, challenge weak coverage positions, keep the insurer to its obligations and protect you if the insurer later refuses to settle within policy limits.

What are Morris and Damron agreements in Arizona?

Arizona gives policyholders two tools that most states don’t, for when an insurer leaves them exposed.

  • Damron agreement: If your insurer refuses to defend you, you may settle with the claimant on your own. You typically agree to a judgment, assign your claims against the insurer to the claimant, and the claimant agrees not to collect from you personally. The claimant then pursues the insurer.
  • Morris agreement: If your insurer defends under a reservation of rights, you may settle without its consent, using a similar structure. You must give the insurer notice, and the settlement must be reasonable. The claimant must then prove coverage and that the settlement amount was reasonable.

Both agreements carry real risk if they are structured or timed badly. They should never be signed without independent coverage counsel.

When should a business hire a policyholder attorney?

Call a policyholder attorney as soon as your insurer:

  • Denies a claim, or approves only part of it without a clear reason
  • Sends a reservation-of-rights letter
  • Refuses to defend you in a lawsuit
  • Keeps asking for documents without making a decision
  • Points to a deadline in the policy you didn’t know existed

Timing matters. Many policies set their own deadlines for notice and for filing suit, and some are shorter than state law. Waiting can cost you rights you didn’t know you had. See The Traps to Avoid When Presenting an Insurance Claim.

What are common insurance coverage disputes for Arizona businesses?

Coverage disputes tend to follow the type of policy involved:

Policy Common dispute
Commercial general liability (CGL) Refusal to defend construction defect or property damage claims; “your work” and “occurrence” arguments
Commercial property Underpaid losses, disputes over cause of loss, wear-and-tear and water exclusions
Builder’s risk Whether damage during construction is a covered loss or excluded faulty workmanship
Business interruption How lost income is calculated and when the coverage period ends
Professional liability / E&O Late-notice and “prior knowledge” denials under claims-made policies
Directors & officers (D&O) Allocation between covered and uncovered claims, and exclusions for insured-vs-insured suits

In each case, the insurer’s first answer isn’t always the final word. For construction policies specifically, see Construction Insurance Types: What’s Covered and What’s Bad Faith? and Arizona’s Guide to Commercial Property Damage Claims. Policy language is often ambiguous, and Arizona courts look at the policy as a whole, including the reasonable expectations of the insured in some situations.

What should I gather before calling a policyholder attorney?

You’ll get faster, better advice if you bring:

  1. The full insurance policy, including all endorsements and the declarations page. Ask your broker if you don’t have a copy.
  2. Every letter and email from the insurer, especially denials and reservation of rights letters
  3. Your claim submission and any proof of loss
  4. The lawsuit, demand letter or notice that triggered the claim
  5. Photos, invoices, repair estimates and other proof of your loss
  6. A short timeline: when the loss happened, when you notified the insurer and every response since

Don’t leave anything out. A lawyer can only give their best advice with the full picture, including the parts you think hurt your case.

Does experience on both sides help?

Yes. Troy Froderman began his career in insurance defense before moving to policyholder work, which he found more rewarding. Knowing how insurers evaluate claims, set reserves and decide when to settle helps a policyholder attorney anticipate the carrier’s next move.

Troy has tried more than 75 cases to a jury and is ranked Tier 1 by Chambers USA for insurance work. Insurers know when a policyholder’s lawyer is prepared to go to trial, and that changes how they negotiate. (See Does Your Lawyer’s Trial Experience Matter in a Business or Insurance Dispute?)

 

FAQ

Is an insurance defense lawyer on my side? They owe you professional duties, but the insurer selects and pays them. On coverage questions, where you and your insurer disagree, you need independent counsel.

What is insurance bad faith in Arizona? Arizona recognizes a claim when an insurer unreasonably denies, delays or underpays benefits it owes its own policyholder. A bad faith claim can allow damages beyond the policy limits.

Can my insurance company’s lawyer advise me on coverage? No. Coverage counsel advises the insurer on whether to pay. For advice on your rights under the policy, you need your own attorney.

Does FR Law Group represent insurance companies? No. FR Law Group represents policyholders, never insurers, in insurance coverage and bad faith disputes.

Has your insurer denied, delayed or underpaid your claim? Contact FR Law Group for a free initial consultation.

4745 N 7th St. Suite 210 Phoenix, AZ 85014 (602) 566-7425