Does Your Lawyer’s Trial Experience Matter If Most Cases Settle?

Does Your Lawyer’s Trial Experience Matter If Most Cases Settle?

| Blog

Does Your Lawyer’s Trial Experience Matter in a Business or Insurance Dispute?

Yes. Most business and insurance disputes settle, but they settle in the shadow of trial. The other side prices a case by asking what happens if it goes to a jury. A lawyer with a real trial record makes that risk credible, which usually leads to better settlement offers and fewer delay tactics.

Fewer civil cases reach a jury today than a generation ago. Many litigators now go years, or whole careers, without trying a case. That can make trial experience sound like a nice extra. In practice, it is one of the strongest levers you have.

If most cases settle, why does trial experience matter?

Because settlement value depends on trial risk. Insurers and corporate defendants assess every case partly by who is on the other side.

If your lawyer has never tried a case, the other side may assume you will take whatever is offered at mediation. If your lawyer has tried dozens, they have to plan for a verdict. Richie Edwards noted on It’s Law, Episode 1 that opposing counsel’s tone changes as soon as Troy Froderman joins a call or email chain.

How does trial experience change negotiations?

A trial-ready lawyer:

  • Builds the case for a jury from day one, so the evidence is ready if talks fail
  • Knows which facts and witnesses will actually persuade jurors, and values the case accordingly
  • Can walk away from a low offer without bluffing
  • Spots weaknesses in the other side’s case that only show up at trial
  • Gives you an honest view of your risk, not just optimism

That last point matters. On It’s Law, Episode 2, Troy described firms that are upbeat from the first meeting until mediation, then suddenly push the client to settle. When a lawyer isn’t prepared to try the case, that turn often comes when you have the least leverage.

What does trial preparation look like from day one?

A trial-focused lawyer doesn’t wait for a trial date to start preparing. From the first weeks of a case, they:

  1. Build the story. They identify the two or three themes a jury or arbitrator will remember, then gather evidence around them.
  2. Lock down documents early. They send preservation letters and collect emails, project records and claim files before anything is lost. (See Spring Cleaning or Spoliation? The Dangers of Destruction.)
  3. Plan depositions for trial. Every deposition is taken knowing which answers may be shown to a jury.
  4. Retain the right experts. Construction, damages and insurance claims-handling experts are chosen for how well they will testify, not just their résumés. (See The Importance of Expert Witnesses in Arizona Construction Litigation.)
  5. Pressure-test the case. They look hard at the other side’s best defenses so you aren’t surprised at mediation or trial.

This work isn’t wasted if the case settles. It is usually why the case settles on good terms.

Does trial experience matter in arbitration?

Yes. Many construction and commercial contracts require arbitration instead of a jury trial. An arbitration hearing still involves opening statements, witness examination, cross-examination, exhibits and closing arguments. The audience is an arbitrator rather than a jury, but the skills are the same.

Jury trial Arbitration hearing
Decision-maker Jury of citizens, with a judge on legal issues One arbitrator or a panel of three, often lawyers or industry experts
Discovery Full discovery under court rules Often limited by the contract or the arbitrator
Appeal Available on legal errors Very limited grounds to overturn an award
Public record Yes Usually private
Skills needed Openings, witness examination, cross-examination, exhibits, closings The same

For more on choosing between them, see Should You Arbitrate or Litigate During a Construction Dispute?

How long does it take to get to trial in Maricopa County?

On It’s Law, Episode 2, Troy Froderman estimated that a civil case in Maricopa County takes at least about two years from filing to jury trial. Appeals can add roughly 8 to 12 months for the first level and another 6 to 8 months for the next.

That timeline is part of every settlement calculation. Insurers and large companies have the money and time to wait. A lawyer who has been through full trials and appeals can tell you honestly what waiting will cost, and when a fair offer beats years of uncertainty. For more on why cases take so long, listen to It’s Law Episode 8: Why Is the Legal System So Slow?

What happens at mediation when the other side believes you’ll go to trial?

Mediation is where most business and insurance disputes are decided. The mediator moves between the parties and tests each side’s risk. The other side’s offers depend heavily on one question: will this lawyer actually try the case?

When the answer is yes, a few things tend to happen:

  • Opening offers are more realistic, because lowball tactics are less likely to work
  • The other side’s decision-makers attend, or are reachable, with real settlement authority
  • Arguments focus on the evidence and likely verdict range, not on outlasting you
  • If no deal is reached, the case moves to trial on schedule instead of drifting

When the answer is no, mediation often becomes a contest of patience, and the side with deeper pockets usually wins it. For a look at what the courtroom itself is like, listen to It’s Law Episode 6: Your Day in the Courtroom.

What should I ask a lawyer about trial experience?

Ask these before you hire:

  1. How many cases have you personally tried to a verdict, to a jury or in arbitration?
  2. When was your most recent trial?
  3. Will you be first chair at trial, or will another lawyer?
  4. How many of your cases like mine went to trial, and what happened?
  5. If the other side won’t make a fair offer, are you prepared to try this case?

Vague answers to questions 1 and 3 are a warning sign.

What trial experience does FR Law Group bring?

Troy Froderman has tried more than 75 cases to a jury over more than three decades of practice. He spent most of his career at large and international firms, where he led a group of about 130 trial lawyers. He is ranked Tier 1 by Chambers USA and recognized in The Best Lawyers in America for insurance litigation and construction law.

FR Law Group is selective about the business litigation and insurance cases it takes. As Troy said on It’s Law, “We don’t take the case unless we’re all in.” Once the firm commits, the case is prepared for trial from the start.

FAQ

Do most business lawsuits go to trial? No. Most settle or are resolved by motion. That’s why the credibility of a lawyer’s trial threat matters so much.

What’s the difference between a litigator and a trial lawyer? A litigator handles the lawsuit process: pleadings, discovery and motions. A trial lawyer also tries cases to verdict. Many litigators rarely or never go to trial.

Does a trial lawyer cost more? Not necessarily. A lawyer who can credibly threaten trial often resolves cases sooner and on better terms, which can lower total cost.

Does trial experience matter in an insurance bad faith case? Yes. Insurers track which policyholder lawyers actually try cases, and that affects how they reserve and negotiate claims.

Facing a business or insurance dispute that may go to trial? Contact FR Law Group for a free initial consultation.

4745 N 7th St. Suite 210 Phoenix, AZ 85014 (602) 566-7425