What Is Outside General Counsel for Construction Companies?

What Is Outside General Counsel for Construction Companies?

| Blog

What Is Outside General Counsel? When a Construction Company Needs One

Outside general counsel is a law firm that acts as a company’s ongoing legal department without being on the payroll. For a construction company, that means one team handling contracts, risk, payment rights, licensing and disputes, and getting to know the business well enough to spot problems before they turn into lawsuits.

Most contractors call a lawyer when something has already gone wrong: a payment is late, an owner is threatening to terminate, or a subcontractor has walked off the job. By then, the contract that decides the outcome was signed months ago. Outside general counsel changes that timing.

What does an outside general counsel do for a construction company?

An outside general counsel handles the legal work an in-house lawyer would, as it comes up:

The value is continuity. As Scott Ryan put it on It’s Law, Episode 1, a firm that works with a client from the start already knows the people, systems and processes when a dispute arises.

How is outside general counsel different from hiring a lawyer for each problem?

A lawyer hired for one dispute starts from zero. They have to learn your company, your contract forms and how your projects run, all on the clock and usually under deadline pressure.

Outside general counsel already has that context. They can also flag a bad clause or a missing notice requirement while there is still time to fix it. That early involvement may cost a little more up front, but it usually saves time and money later.

How does an outside general counsel relationship start?

A good outside general counsel relationship is built before the first dispute. A typical start looks like this:

  1. Kickoff meeting. The firm learns how your company runs: who signs contracts, who manages projects, your typical project size and your biggest past headaches.
  2. Contract form review. Your standard subcontracts, purchase orders and proposal terms are updated to fit Arizona law and your risk tolerance. A playbook is set for the owner clauses you will and won’t accept.
  3. Risk program. Your project managers get a practical checklist for spotting risky clauses, notice deadlines and insurance gaps. FR Law Group offers its contract risk management program, which Scott Ryan developed over 20 years, to clients in person or virtually.
  4. Notice and payment protocols. Simple procedures for preliminary notices, change order requests, delay notices and lien deadlines, so nothing slips through on a busy job.
  5. Ongoing access. One point of contact for quick questions, regular check-ins and a firm that already knows the background when something escalates.

When does a construction company need outside general counsel?

It is usually time when one or more of these is true:

  • You are bidding larger or more complex projects than before
  • You sign several contracts a month and no one is reviewing them consistently
  • You have had a payment, lien or change order dispute in the past year
  • You are expanding into a new state or market
  • Your team is spending project hours on legal questions
  • You don’t have enough legal work to justify a full-time in-house lawyer

What can go wrong without construction counsel? Two examples

A missed lien deadline. A subcontractor finishes a $400,000 scope of work and the general contractor stops paying. The subcontractor assumes it can record a mechanics’ lien. But it never served the preliminary twenty-day notice that Arizona requires to protect lien rights, and the recording deadline has passed. Its strongest payment remedy is gone. With outside counsel, a notice protocol would have been set on day one.

A verbal change order. A superintendent tells a contractor’s crew to add work “and we’ll sort out the paperwork later.” The contract requires signed change orders and written notice within a set number of days. The contractor completes $150,000 of extra work, submits the request weeks later, and the owner denies it as untimely. Outside counsel would have flagged that notice clause at signing and trained the team to protect the claim in writing.

Neither problem needed a lawsuit to prevent. Both often end in one.

Outside general counsel vs. in-house counsel: which is right for you?

Outside general counsel In-house counsel
Cost Pay for the work you need Full salary, benefits and overhead
Breadth A team covering contracts, insurance and litigation Usually one lawyer, who sends specialized work outside
Construction experience Built from many clients and projects Depends on the hire
Litigation Can take a dispute through trial Usually hires outside trial counsel
Best fit Small and mid-sized contractors, developers and suppliers Large contractors with steady, high-volume legal work

Many companies use both: an in-house lawyer for daily matters and outside counsel for specialized construction, insurance and trial work.

How is outside general counsel billed?

Fee structures vary by firm and by how much work you expect to send. The most common options:

  • Hourly: You pay for time spent. This works well when legal needs are occasional and hard to predict.
  • Monthly fee: A set amount covers a defined scope, such as contract reviews and routine questions. It makes legal costs predictable for budgeting.
  • Project-based: A fixed fee for a defined task, such as rewriting your subcontract form or negotiating one owner agreement.
  • Hybrid: A monthly fee for routine work, with disputes and litigation billed separately.

Whatever the structure, ask for it in writing. A good engagement letter states the rates, what is included, how out-of-pocket costs are approved and how often you’ll be billed.

Why does construction experience matter?

Construction contracts are full of industry-specific risk: schedule float, differing site conditions, pass-through claims, flow-down provisions and payment conditions. A lawyer who understands how a project actually runs can read those clauses for their real-world impact.

Scott Ryan holds undergraduate and graduate degrees in construction and worked as a project engineer for a national contractor before law school. He later spent about 13 years as general counsel, ending as senior vice president and general counsel of a group of building companies that delivered projects worth hundreds of millions to billions of dollars. FR Law Group’s outside general counsel service is built on that in-house experience.

FAQ

How much does outside general counsel cost? It depends on how much work you send. Arrangements can be hourly, project-based or a monthly fee. For most small and mid-sized contractors, it costs far less than a full-time in-house lawyer.

Can outside general counsel handle litigation? Yes, if the firm has trial lawyers. FR Law Group handles construction disputes from the first notice letter through arbitration or trial. (See why trial experience matters.)

Do I still need outside general counsel if I use standard AIA contracts? Yes. Standard forms are almost always modified, and the changes are where the risk sits. They also may not match Arizona law on indemnity, payment or liens.

Is outside general counsel only for contractors? No. Developers, owners, subcontractors and suppliers use it too.

Want a construction lawyer who already knows your business when a problem comes up? Contact FR Law Group about outside general counsel services.

4745 N 7th St. Suite 210 Phoenix, AZ 85014 (602) 566-7425